Blue Moon Pizza

Share This Loyalty Program

Facebook Twitter
Blue Moon Pizza Bars & Clubs | Cape May, New Jersey, 08204 | Reviews, Local Offers

Blue Moon Pizza

425 Beach Ave., Cape May, NJ 08204

Average Review: 4 Star Rating: Good

Phone: (609) 884-3303

Wifi Access: No

Categories: Bars & Clubs

Website: http://www.bluemooncapemay.com/

Listing Information:

Follow Us Reviews

Location & Hours:

425 Beach Ave.
Cape May, New Jersey, 08204
(609) 884-3303

Customer Experience:

MenuFeedback Rating: Silver

Silver Member


Blue Moon Pizza's See Inside Tour

Blue Moon Pizza's Street View

Blue Moon Pizza Reviews

  • by Asa Taylor on 03/11/2018
  • Rating:2 Star Rating: Below Average
  • I’m not leaving a review for the food but only my experience. My taco pizza and smothered fries never arrived soooo I’d like to think it would have been delicious but I can’t say for sure. We were staying at a local historic hotel for vacation and wanted a late second dinner if you will. We placed an order online for delivery at 10:30 on a Sunday because most other places were closed and Blue Moon says their hours are 11am to midnight. We had the confirmation email at 10:32 that our order was accepted. We got an email at 11:10 stating that our card was charged so we assumed that our food was on the way since typically you aren’t billed until your food is made and on its way. At 11:30 we got another email saying that unfortunately the establishment was closed and our order was cancelled. So I proceeded to call Blue Moon and a man picked up the phone and then hung up on me. I called again and then possibly the same man answered and I explained that we had placed an order an hour ago, that’s an hour and a half well before closing, and that we sat and waited for it to come only to get an email telling us that they were closed. He apologized and said they were closed even though they should be open for another half an hour. Now I work in the food industry and can’t imagine they would close at 10:30 or earlier and still be there at 11:30, I heard multiple people in the background leading me to think they were still actually open. My conclusion is that they were open but didn’t want to make our order and deliver it because ya know that’s just easier. Had I known I would have been lied to I would have walked down myself and ordered it in person then I wouldn’t have gotten the cold shoulder. And here I am writing this review sad and hungry. Thanks for nothing Blue Moon.
  • by Alex E on 07/11/2017
  • Rating:5 Star Rating: Excellent
  • I ordered the Gyro King and it came out in good time and tasted very delicious. I was with a group and they ordered salads. It was a good portion size even for the house salad. The service was overall phenomenal, as the waitress greeted us promptly and was very kind throughout the entire order. The setting is very casual and laid back. I would definitely recommend this place for their Mediterranean food and salads. Their pizza selection is very large and many of them look delicious. I would come back just for the service though!
  • by HugeMedal Gaming on 07/06/2017
  • Rating:5 Star Rating: Excellent
  • Great people and great food. We ordered 10 pizzas and they came on time and the food was very good. I highly recommend to come here. They are genuinely one of the nicest people you could meet. The food was perfect, and being there just reminded me of home. It was great. So, if you are ever in Cape May come eat at Blue Moon Pizza.
  • by Heather Hamilton-Cuzzocrea on 07/19/2017
  • Rating:5 Star Rating: Excellent
  • This place was great! We got the burgers and fries, and cheese sticks with sauce. Everything was awesome. The sauce for the cheese sticks was amazing! The staff was wonderful, too. I would highly recommend Blue Moon Pizza!!
  • by Fernando Barajas on 11/21/2017
  • Rating:5 Star Rating: Excellent
  • The best chicken ceasar salad ever. I love this place

  • by Gunny R. on 10/01/2017 Never had their pizza, but Blue Moon makes THEEE BEST cheesesteak sandwiches, hands down. Delivered fast and piping hot! I'll be a new regular here!
View review stats

Kind Words

No testimonials yet


No events currently listed.

Access this page on mobile to claim your rewards.
You are viewing the desktop version, some features may be unavailable.